Sign in
← All bills
HB 459Just filedCourts & legal system

Sets conditions for using a defendant's creative work as evidence at trial

The short version · AI summary

Creates a new rule in criminal trials. A defendant's creative work, such as music, poetry, film, visual art or writing, could not be used against the defendant at the guilt or punishment phase unless prosecutors give notice and a judge holds a hearing without the jury present. The judge must find that the work was meant literally, was made near the time of or closely matches the alleged offense, relates to a disputed fact or has non-public detail, and that its probative value substantially outweighs unfair prejudice. It applies to proceedings starting on or after September 1, 2027.

What it means for you

Most people would notice nothing. If someone is charged with a crime, their songs, poems or films would be harder for prosecutors to use as evidence against them.

One email when it moves, at most one a day. Unsubscribe in one click from any email.

Bill Facts

HB 459 · Filed Nov 9, 2026
Who it affects
  • Defendants in criminal trials
  • Prosecutors
  • Judges
  • Artists, writers and musicians charged with crimes
What changes
  • A defendant's music, poetry, film or other creative work could not be used against them unless prosecutors give notice first.
  • A judge would hold a hearing without the jury to decide if the work can be used.
  • The judge must find the work was meant literally, closely matches the crime, and is more helpful than unfairly harmful as evidence.
When it starts
September 1, 2027, for trials that begin on or after that date, if it becomes law
What it changes
2 tags, with the bill’s own words

What it changes

Each tag says one thing the bill changes, with the bill’s own words. A major tag reaches many people, a lot of money or a core right.

Protects a right or privacy

Major

Bars use of a defendant's creative expression as evidence unless strict conditions are met, adding protection for expressive works in all criminal trials.

Quoted from the bill text
A defendant's work of creative expression is not admissible against the defendant in a criminal trial, whether offered in the guilt or innocence phase or the punishment phase of the trial, unless:

Adds limits or oversight

Minor

Requires prosecutors to give notice and a judge to make findings at a separate hearing before the work can be shown to the jury.

Quoted from the bill text
in a hearing conducted outside the presence of the jury, the judge finds by a preponderance of the evidence that:

Reviewed by AI on Nov 12, 2026 · Reviewed text version I

How reviews work
  • The plain-words summaries and notes are written by AI, not by a person.
  • Every quote is checked against the bill, letter for letter, before it is shown. A note whose words cannot be found in the bill is dropped.
  • Editors may correct a summary, an area of life or a note.

Where it is now

A bill is filed first. Then it goes to a committee, a small group of lawmakers who study it. After that, the House and the Senate each vote.

  1. Step 1
    Filed
    A lawmaker turned the bill in.
    You are here.
  2. Step 2
    A committee studies it
    A small group of lawmakers studies the bill, holds a hearing and votes.
  3. Step 3
    One side votes
    The House or the Senate votes on the bill.
  4. Step 4
    The other side votes
    The other part votes too.
  5. Step 5
    The governor decides
    The governor signs the bill into law or vetoes it, which means says no.

The bill, word for word

This is the bill as filed. A bill that changes a law shows what it adds and what it removes.

The record

Bill text
Session
90th Legislature, regular session
Author
John Bucy
Subjects
Arts & Humanities, Courts--Prosecuting Attorneys, Criminal Procedure--General
Documents
None yet
Witnesses
None yet

What happened so far

Every official action on this bill, newest first.

  1. Nov 9, 2026
    Filed
HB 459: Sets conditions for using a defendant's creative work as evidence at trial | 51capitol